Comments on: Who is the idiot here? http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/ It's our time now! Mon, 06 Sep 2010 10:01:36 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.1 By: harsh http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/#comment-20624 harsh Wed, 09 Jun 2010 11:44:01 +0000 http://www.makesplash.com/?p=3851#comment-20624 rather a daring comment on hindustan times columnist. How u r so sure abt minute details of the contract ? rather a daring comment on hindustan times columnist. How u r so sure abt minute details of the contract ?

]]> By: Health Benefits of Baking with Splenda | Cooking Advice http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/#comment-19227 Health Benefits of Baking with Splenda | Cooking Advice Sun, 24 Jan 2010 00:55:53 +0000 http://www.makesplash.com/?p=3851#comment-19227 [...] Who is the idiot here? « makeSplash.com by Sush Jaitly [...] [...] Who is the idiot here? « makeSplash.com by Sush Jaitly [...]

]]> By: Ankit Jain http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/#comment-19219 Ankit Jain Fri, 22 Jan 2010 14:39:58 +0000 http://www.makesplash.com/?p=3851#comment-19219 Dear Sush. I think your views are more reactive , Yes I agree with you that Chetan Bhagat was not given enough room in the movie but 5 Point someone is merely a book devoid of any messages and just a time pass overhyped novel . The novel got the hype out of IIT tag .I believe the Movie 3 idiots might have shown few larger than life characters but we all need role models. Infact the whole Bhagat aamir feud looks to me just a publicity stunt to increase the sales of both the novel and the movie. You might like to go through my complete views on the same and also on one of the other novels of Mr. Bhagat which are devoid of any quality and full of mistakes. http://ankit-freedom.blogspot.com/search/label/Chetan%20Bhagat Regards Dear Sush.

I think your views are more reactive , Yes I agree with you that Chetan Bhagat was not given enough room in the movie but 5 Point someone is merely a book devoid of any messages and just a time pass overhyped novel . The novel got the hype out of IIT tag .I believe the Movie 3 idiots might have shown few larger than life characters but we all need role models. Infact the whole Bhagat aamir feud looks to me just a publicity stunt to increase the sales of both the novel and the movie.

You might like to go through my complete views on the same and also on one of the other novels of Mr. Bhagat which are devoid of any quality and full of mistakes.

http://ankit-freedom.blogspot.com/search/label/Chetan%20Bhagat

Regards

]]> By: anjugandhi http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/#comment-19164 anjugandhi Wed, 13 Jan 2010 16:44:13 +0000 http://www.makesplash.com/?p=3851#comment-19164 you are right, Chetan Bhagat's new book will be a success his acts have brought him so much publicity although i do believe that the director and producers should have acknolwdged his work in the titles. may be something like story idea or concept you are right, Chetan Bhagat’s new book will be a success his acts have brought him so much publicity
although i do believe that the director and producers should have acknolwdged his work in the titles.
may be something like story idea or concept

]]> By: K.P. Prashanth http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/#comment-19125 K.P. Prashanth Sun, 10 Jan 2010 11:17:00 +0000 http://www.makesplash.com/?p=3851#comment-19125 Fact of the matter is not in just this one incident. If you go by the very recent controversies you will perhaps agree that there exists a potential hidden claimant for almost every good piece of work that comes out, be it in art, literature, drama, movie etc. It has sort of become a fab today, maybe for instant publicity, to lay claim to what would perhaps remotely coincide with your views but broadly different in perception of the other. And the controversy begins......well I suppose such matters are best left at that. Fact of the matter is not in just this one incident. If you go by the very recent controversies you will perhaps agree that there exists a potential hidden claimant for almost every good piece of work that comes out, be it in art, literature, drama, movie etc. It has sort of become a fab today, maybe for instant publicity, to lay claim to what would perhaps remotely coincide with your views but broadly different in perception of the other. And the controversy begins……well I suppose such matters are best left at that.

]]> By: Hari http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/#comment-19121 Hari Sat, 09 Jan 2010 00:16:33 +0000 http://www.makesplash.com/?p=3851#comment-19121 This is a strange controversy in an industry that has no quams about coping stories, music and other material from other movie industries particularly Hollywood without paying for or acknowledging the copyrights. This is a strange controversy in an industry that has no quams about coping stories, music and other material from other movie industries particularly Hollywood without paying for or acknowledging the copyrights.

]]> By: Shaan http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/#comment-19119 Shaan Fri, 08 Jan 2010 19:41:52 +0000 http://www.makesplash.com/?p=3851#comment-19119 You hit the nail on the head! Yes, I too had the impression that Vir Singhvi is a big fool to write such a long column in support of Cheat-n-brag-art. But you cannot call Chetan so smart, because in the enthusiasm of getting his story made into a movie he even did not care to read the agreement properly. Rajkumar Hirani has in fact permanently damaged Chetan's reputation by putting online Chetan's previous interview and agreement in <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=neHsWIaSVPw" rel="nofollow">Youtube</a>. The whole episode inspired <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xivUGtreUTY" rel="nofollow">this video</a>. You hit the nail on the head! Yes, I too had the impression that Vir Singhvi is a big fool to write such a long column in support of Cheat-n-brag-art. But you cannot call Chetan so smart, because in the enthusiasm of getting his story made into a movie he even did not care to read the agreement properly. Rajkumar Hirani has in fact permanently damaged Chetan’s reputation by putting online Chetan’s previous interview and agreement in Youtube. The whole episode inspired this video.

]]> By: swami www ji http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/#comment-19114 swami www ji Fri, 08 Jan 2010 07:43:33 +0000 http://www.makesplash.com/?p=3851#comment-19114 ha ha hahhh.... good one sush as usual... i always love chetans books.... hes a down to earth practical thinker and writer!!! ha ha hahhh…. good one sush as usual… i always love chetans books…. hes a down to earth practical thinker and writer!!!

]]> By: Shailesh Tinaikar http://www.makesplash.com/who-is-the-idiot-here/#comment-19113 Shailesh Tinaikar Fri, 08 Jan 2010 06:18:36 +0000 http://www.makesplash.com/?p=3851#comment-19113 Sush, the base idea is that of Chetan Bhagat, modified and adapted for the film. Grace and good sense demands that he be given credit. Hence, to call the story of the movie as an Original Story is being economical with truth if not a complete travesty. Sensitivity of the writer to his creation must be respected. Our music directors are inspired by western compositions and they get away with it. The same with our film story writers. Chetan Bhagat has the gumption to stand up to the power of the film industry. Try writing an original score. Its not easy. Lets respect talent. The movie is good. The controversy should rest. Hopefully Chetan Bhagat and other good story writers are more conscious while selling their rights to others in future. Producers/Directors too should be fair and reasonable.. I do hope that the movie filters through to the youth of India and their parents. Children being forced fit to follow their parent's dreams is the biggest single concern facing us today. Who cares who makes money in the process.. Somebody has to... Sush, the base idea is that of Chetan Bhagat, modified and adapted for the film. Grace and good sense demands that he be given credit. Hence, to call the story of the movie as an Original Story is being economical with truth if not a complete travesty. Sensitivity of the writer to his creation must be respected. Our music directors are inspired by western compositions and they get away with it. The same with our film story writers. Chetan Bhagat has the gumption to stand up to the power of the film industry.

Try writing an original score. Its not easy. Lets respect talent.

The movie is good. The controversy should rest. Hopefully Chetan Bhagat and other good story writers are more conscious while selling their rights to others in future. Producers/Directors too should be fair and reasonable..

I do hope that the movie filters through to the youth of India and their parents. Children being forced fit to follow their parent’s dreams is the biggest single concern facing us today. Who cares who makes money in the process.. Somebody has to…

]]>